Philosophy Lexicon of Arguments

Motion: spatial variation of one or more observed or not observed objects in time. Problems arising in connection with attribution or withdrawal of predicates. See also change, temporal identity, process, flux, vectors.
Author Item Excerpt Meta data
Frith, Chris
Books on Amazon
Motion I 187
Movement/cognition/perception/life/Frith: from the way something moves, one can see whether it is a living being or, for example, a leaf.
For example, about 14 light points are attached to the joints of a human being. The human then moves in a dark room.
N.B.: if you only look at a single moving point, you cannot see anything sensible in the movement. Even if all 14 points do not move, you cannot see anything sensible! In movements you immediately recognize something sensible. One can even say whether the figure is happy or sad. (E.g.
N.B.: even cats can be trained to recognize a cat from the points, and to recognize when the points are arranged randomly.
I 194
Movement/Interpretation/Objective/Intention/Frith: In movements, the internal models are the goals of the action.
Problem: Movements are ambiguous. E.g. I can go to the baker next door or to Patagonia.
I 195
Movement/Interpretation: E.g. the person opposite me should repeat everything I do. I raise my left hand, the other raises the right. Is this a mistake?
E.g. I take the right hand and touch my left ear, the other person takes the left hand and touches his left ear. Is this a mistake?
N.B.: now to the correct test: in the middle of the table is a big red button. I lean forward and touch it with my forehead. What the other is doing depends on my hands: if I have chained hands, but the other person does not, he will use his hands, when I have free hands, the other person will use his heads.
I 197
Movement/Imitation/Interpretation/Frith: For example, the subject should move the arm rhythmically up and down while watching another person, moving the arms rhythmically sideways.
This shows that we unconsciously tend to imitate others.
N.B.: when the person moving sideways was replaced by a robot, the unconscious imitation did not happen.
I 198
Movement/Action/Brain/Interpretation/Frith: Thesis: in the robot the brain registers only movements but no actions.

Frith I
Chris Frith
Wie unser Gehirn die Welt erschafft Heidelberg 2013

> Counter arguments against Frith

> Suggest your own contribution | > Suggest a correction | > Export as BibTeX file
Ed. Martin Schulz, access date 2017-04-28