Find counter arguments by entering NameVs… or …VsName.
The author or concept searched is found in the following 1 entries.
| Disputed term/author/ism | Author |
Entry |
Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qualia | Shoemaker | Stalnaker I 220 Qualia/common sense/Shoemaker: Thesis: Qualia are internal, intrinsic, but also locally comparable. >Intrinsicness, >Internalism, >Localization, >Comparability. VsFrege-Schlick view. > StalnakerVsShoemaker: per "old-fashioned" Frege-Schlick view. >Inverted spectra. |
Shoemaker I S. Shoemaker Identity, Cause, and Mind: Philosophical Essays Expanded Edition 2003 Stalnaker I R. Stalnaker Ways a World may be Oxford New York 2003 |
| |||
| Disputed term/author/ism | Author Vs Author |
Entry |
Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frege, G. | Nagel Vs Frege, G. | III 107 Psychology/Nagel: it is characteristic for psychological terms that we imagine they could be separated from the objective side effects! E.g. the question whether sugar tastes for other people like "this here" is a perfectly well-defined question! Even if it is unanswerable! ((s) NagelVsFrege/NagelVsSchlick/ >Cresswell II "Frege-Schlick view")). |
NagE I E. Nagel The Structure of Science: Problems in the Logic of Scientific Explanation Cambridge, MA 1979 Nagel I Th. Nagel The Last Word, New York/Oxford 1997 German Edition: Das letzte Wort Stuttgart 1999 Nagel II Thomas Nagel What Does It All Mean? Oxford 1987 German Edition: Was bedeutet das alles? Stuttgart 1990 Nagel III Thomas Nagel The Limits of Objectivity. The Tanner Lecture on Human Values, in: The Tanner Lectures on Human Values 1980 Vol. I (ed) St. M. McMurrin, Salt Lake City 1980 German Edition: Die Grenzen der Objektivität Stuttgart 1991 NagelEr I Ernest Nagel Teleology Revisited and Other Essays in the Philosophy and History of Science New York 1982 |
| |||
The author or concept searched is found in the following 4 theses of the more related field of specialization.
| Disputed term/author/ism | Author |
Entry |
Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qualia | Frege, G. | Staln I 220 Qualia / common sense / Shoemaker: Thesis: qualia are internal, intrinsic, locally but also comparable. VsFrege-Schlick-view. Qualia / Frege-Schlick-view / Shoemaker: Thesis: qualia are not comparable, because it is meaningless to assume that e.g. exchanged spectra represent anything communicable. Interpersonal comparisons of phenomenal experience are meaningless. |
|
| Reversed Spectra | Frege, G. | Staln I 226 exchanged spectra / common sense / Stalnaker: qualitative properties are local and intrinsic properties of experiences. Frege-Schlick view: qualitative properties are relational. |
|
| Qualia | Schlick, M. | Staln I 220 Qualia / common sense / Shoemaker: Qualia are internal, intrinsic - but also locally comparable. Against: Frege-Schlick-View: / Shoemaker: Thesis: qualia are not comparable, because it is meaningless to assume that e.g. exchanged spectra represent anything communicable. Interpersonal comparisons of phenomenal experience are meaningless. |
|
| Reversed Spektra | Stalnaker, R. | I 222 Reversed Spectra/Symmetry/Stalnaker: Suppose (as the thesis of the interchanged spectra does) that the relational structure is symmetric (in some way). I 223 Shoemaker: that would be too easy. Thesis: he wants to reconcile interpersonal comparisons of Qualia with a functionalist approach. Although we cannot functionally define certain qualitative states, we can define classes of qualitative states as follows: I 226 Reversed Spectra/common sense/Stalnaker: Thesis: qualitative properties are local and intrinsic properties of experiences. Frege-Schlick-View: Thesis: qualitative properties are relational. |
|
| |||